Thursday, December 15, 2011

Eocetus, "Eocetus", and Friends

Update (January 28, 2014): "Eocetus" wardii is now Basilotritus wardii. More on my new post, The Third King.


I was shocked that Uhen (2010) remarked that Basilosaurus drazindai and Basiloterus hussaini "probably represent protocetids... akin to Eocetus". This would place the whales outside Pelagiceti and imply that the now-questionable basilosaurids were potentially capable of walking on land, despite being enormous. Unfortunately, other mentions of this revised placement give no further details (Uhen 2008, Uhen et al. 2011) and Uhen (2010) further states the placement is "difficult to determine with certainty" due to scarce materials. I suspect the hypothesis will not be officially discussed until further material is found and/or described... which won't stop me from wildly speculating.

Lumbar vertebrae in right lateral view. From left to right: "Eocetus" wardii (from Uhen 1999), Basiloterus hussaini, and Basilosaurus drazindai - note that the latter-most may be an anterior caudal (from Gingerich et al. 1997). For comparison: Basilosaurus isis vertebrae.
In the description of Basilosaurus drazindai, Gingerich et al. (1997) note a number of "primitive retentions" which resemble the morphology of "generalized archaeocetes": long neural spine and arch; broad, almost-horizontally placed, anterior-projecting metapophyses which project beyond the anterior edge of the vertebral centrum; and paired, posterolateral processes of the neural arch. Aside from the last trait (which I can't confirm without a dorsal view), all of these traits are present in "Eocetus" (Uhen 1999). Additionally, "Eocetus" has elongated transverse processes, unlike the condition of Basilosaurus (Uhen 1999); however, B. drazindai has processes with a 15.5 cm long base (they broke off) relative to the 30 cm centrum (Gingerich et al. 1997), and so probably had a similar, albeit slightly less extreme, condition. The only criterion for placing B. drazindai in the genus Basilosaurus was the size and shape of the centrum (Gingerich et al. 1997), and while they are uncannily similar in shape, everything else seems to be pointing towards a relationship with "Eocetus".

Lumbar vertebrae in anterior view. Ditto order.
As for awkward middle-child Basiloterus, it appears to have a centrum which is slightly more elongated than that of "Eocetus", however the neural arch and maybe the neural spine appear to be narrower. The metapophyses are upwardly-angled (Gingerich et al. 1997), less broad, less anterior-projecting, but still appear to extend past the centrum. The posterolateral processes are absent (Gingerich et al. 1997). The base of the transverse process is 9.3 cm long relative to a 19.5-20 cm centra (Gingerich et al. 1997), proportionally similar to Basilosaurus drazindai. The placement of Basiloterus is thus not clear, and perhaps it was a basilosaurid or an even more derived protocetid.

Maiacetus inuus, a basal "protocetid" (Uhen 2011). From Wikipedia Commons.

Protocetidae is a blatantly paraphyletic "family" of extinct cetaceans from Eocene coastal marine deposits with hip and femur morphology indicating amphibious capabilities (most of the time) and no evidence of flukes (Uhen 2010). Uhen (1999) appears to think that "Eocetuswardii had weight-bearing hips, however Uhen (2010) refers to them as "moderately reduced" and regarded the species as possibly non-amphibious. This is perhaps not surprising since Eocetus, "Eocetus", and an unnamed Pisco Formation species are the sister group of Pelagiceti (Uhen et al. 2011). This could make them closer relatives of Dorudon than Maiacetus, and raises the question of how many typical protocetid traits they actually exhibited. Perhaps they were entirely aquatic tail-based swimmers which just happened to have fairly large vestigial legs.

Dorudon atrox. From Wikipedia Commons.
The scare quotes around "Eocetus" hint at a taxonomic misadventure. "E." wardii was assigned to its genus by Uhen (1999) based on comparisons of its skull and vertebrae to Eocetus schweinfurthi; the problem is, the holotype of E. schweinfurthi is an isolated skull and it is not possible to determine whether the vertebrae referred to it actually represent the species (Geisler et al. 2005). There is overlapping skull material (Uhen 1999), but Geisler et al. (2005) apparently regarded it as too incomplete to warrant unambiguous placement in the genus. Somehow, "Eocetus" and Eocetus formed a clade in phylogenetic analyses (Geisler et al. 2005, Uhen et al. 2011), making it probable that future discoveries will confirm their close relationship.

"Eocetus" wardii is clearly related to unnamed Pisco Formation material which exhibits the same distinctive traits (moderate centrum elongation, elongated neural arches and spines and transverse processes, strange pock-marked texture) with the only difference being that the unnamed material is 35% smaller (Uhen et al. 2011). The Egyptian vertebrae dubiously assigned to Eocetus schweinfurthi (figured in Uhen 1999) also seem quite similar (including the pock-marks), and if it is also a member of this clade, it would indicate a sizable trans-oceanic range. This in turn could be taken as evidence of the whales being largely pelagic... of course this is quite speculative.

There of course remains much to be known about these cetaceans, and perhaps future discoveries will be enlightening as to how similar they were to the pelagic cetaceans, as well as the origins of Pelagiceti. I really hope it turns out that a Basilosaurus-sized animal could walk on land.


References:

Geisler, J. H., Sanders, A. E., and Luo, Z-X. (2005). A New Protocetid Whale (Cetacea: Archaeoceti) from the Late Middle Eocene of South Carolina. American Museum Novitates 3480, 1-65. Available.

Gingerich, P. D., Arif, M., Bhatti, M. A., Anwar, M., & Sanders, W. J. (1997). Basilosaurus drazindai and Basiloterus hussaini, new Archaeoceti (Mammalia, Cetacea) from the middle Eocene Drazinda Formation, with a revised interpretation of ages of whale-bearing strata in the Kirthar Group of the Sulaiman Range, Punjab (Pakistan). Contributions from the Museum of Paleontology, University of Michigan 30 (2), 55-81. Available.

Uhen, M. D., Pyenson, N. D., Devries, T. J., Urbina, M., and Renne, P. R. (2011). New middle Eocene whales from the Pisco Basin of Peru. Journal of Paleontology 85(5), 955-969. doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.1666/10-162.1

Uhen, M. D. (2010). The Origin(s) of Whales. Annual Review of Earth and Planetary Sciences 38, 189–221. Available.

Uhen, M. D. (2008). Basilosaurids. In: Perrin, W. F., Würsig, B., and Thewissen, J. G. M. (eds.) Encyclopedia of Marine Mammals, Second Edition. Elsevier: Burlington, Massachusetts. Available.

Uhen, M. D. (1999). New Species of Protocetid Archaeocete Whale, Eocetus wardii (Mammalia: Cetacea) from the Middle Eocene of North Carolina. Journal of Paleontology 73(3), 512-528.

Weems, R. E., Edwards, L. E., Osborne, J. E., and Alford, A. A. (2011). An occurrence of the protocetid whale "Eocetus" wardii in the Middle Eocene formation of Virginia. Journal of Paleontology 85(2), 271-278. Available.

52 comments:

Allen Hazen said...

Slightly tangential question: how, in Cetacea derived enough that there is no longer a "Sacro-iliac"connection such as is found in land mammals, do you distinguish lumbar from "anterior caudal" vertebrae? I have looked at mounted skeletons of modern cetacea, and failed to spot any obvious transition in form. ... Eventually you get to centra that have chevrons below them (below and between...), and I take it that these ought to be classified as caudal--but are ONLY the centra with chevrons caudals?
With enough soft anatomy (which I'm not sure we have!), you could determine which vertebrae are closest to the innominate remnants, and they might be fair candidates for classification as sacra's, particularly if (is this the case?) they have some sort of ligamental connection to the vertebrae. ... Mounted skeletons typically have the hind-limb remnants suspended beneath the backbone, and I have wondered whether their exact location (which vertebrae are immediately over them) are known or guess-work!
(B.t.w.: your cetacean blogs are appreciated even when not commented on!)

Cameron McCormick said...

Yep, the vertebrae with chevrons (or "ventral/haemal midline processes") are caudals. While some early workers thought they could distinguish sacrals (I remember Kellogg listed Basilosaurus with them), they're just lumped in with lumbars now. There doesn't seem to be any way to determine where the hindlimbs of fossil whales with unattached innominates are, other than presumably floating somewhere right before the tail.

Whales of the World and Buchholtz and Schur(2004) have pretty good reviews that are freely available.

Cameron McCormick said...

Oh, and it means a lot that somebody out there appreciates these! At some point I'll write about Basilosaurus, but I keep on running into these other interesting whales...

Allen Hazen said...

BAsilosaurus, humbug! I learned about it from Herbert S. Zim's "The Great Whales" when I was a small child in the 1950s, and Zim called it Zeuglodon. So, ICZN and priority be damned, I'll always think of it as Zeuglodon.
---
And Merry Christmas to you! (Thank you for the references, which I will study after Christmas.)

electronic cigarettes said...

Break Security’s Web Application Penetration Assessment takes on a website from the viewpoint of a malicious hacker, and locate any logical, technical defects.electronic cigarettesthsClic arisen

bowtrol colon cleanse review said...

I just wanted to say that I found your site via Goolge and I am glad I did. Keep up the good work and I will make sure to bookmark you for when I have more free time away from the books. Thanks again!bowtrol colon cleanse review

Garcinia cambogia 75% said...

I just now wished to claim that we discovered your site by way of Goolge along with I'm Garcinia cambogia 75% pleased I did so. Maintain the nice perform along with I most certainly will be sure to save anyone regarding while i convey more sparetime clear of the guides.

Ibeacons online said...

I recently wished to point out which i discovered your site via Goolge along with My business is delighted Used to do. Ibeacons online Maintain the great work along with I'll make sure to save an individual pertaining to once i have an overabundance of sparetime clear of this guides.

Escort Svizzera said...

I definitely enjoying every little bit of it. It is a great website and nice share. I want to thank you. Good job! You guys do a great blog, and have some great contents. Keep up the good work. Escort Svizzera

Watercolor Paintings for sale said...

You need to educate yourself on the best muscle building methods, if you want to achieve the results you're looking for. Focus on the dead lift, dead-lifts and bench presses.These exercises are the best for building a good body.Watercolor Paintings for sale

Tree Doctor said...

It looks as though someone loved your site so much they decided to
bookmark it. I’ll definitely be coming back here more often.Tree Doctor

iWebHostingCoupons said...

very big day in Olamau and the race is on. I love to see this kind of race because it is very exciting.iWebHostingCoupons

vistaprint coupon code said...

Truly, this article is really one of the very best in the history of articles. I am a antique ’Article’ collector and I sometimes read some new articles if I find them interesting. And I found this one pretty fascinating and it should go into my collection. Very good work!!vistaprint coupon code

When I'm free of expense, I generally scan online journals on the web. I like the look and style of your web journal. I think you furthermore made an incredible showing of offering advantageous data. Keep it up! said...

I recently added your site to my top picks. I truly appreciate perusing your posts. A debt of gratitude is in order regarding your Great post and I am anticipating perused your next post.

Visit : Online High School Diploma

GED Online said...

It was nice to land on this website post and to see such superb stuff. Your website is choked with authentic and highly-researched knowledge that's price reading. I’ll sure enough advocate your website to my fellows!

Pakaian Casual Wanita Model Sekarang 2015 said...

I have seen your awareness about this theme when you post it and it really gives an informational message to us readers. I am hoping that you will continue writing this kind

toko green world global said...

I was confused to comment, if I exaggerated when I said it was a remarkable article. I was amazed by the contents and it would like to continue reading even if the eyes are tired. really good article anyway. may I share articles like this obat untuk penyakit tumor otak cara menurunkan kolesterol tinggi cara mengobati impotensi The article discusses health treatment. The next article also discusses the same thing akibat usus kotor dan cara membersihkannya obat herbal menurunkan gula darah tinggi obat untuk mengatasi anemia these articles I created to share information that might be useful for everyone cara menyembuhkan penyakit jantung gejala dan pengobatan prostat hiperplasia I'd love sharing goodness as with this article, hopefully it can benefit others.

Unknown said...

travel itinerary my most fun you willing to want to try : vietnam travel agency chicago | bhaya classic cruise halong bay | bai tho deluxe junk boat | Asia tours bangkok

Unknown said...


I agree, for the most part, but don’t you feel as if the issue is more complex than that?


poker online indonesia

Unknown said...

This is a good site! come on and join with us!


poker online , judi bola

Drug Prices said...

By praying and trying to hopefully make the best result amen? Thanks be visited this pageDrug Prices

80’s costumes said...

Plantar fasciitis is often the cause of heel pain seen by podiatrists although many other causes exist. A thorough exam is important to achieve an accurate diagnosis and targeted treatment.80’s costumes

harada57 said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Unknown said...

Thanks for the information and who are looking for these media. I think it is very useful.


เติมเงิน gclub

Legal Herbal Online said...

After reading your article I was amazed. I know that you explain it very well. And I hope that other readers will also experience how I feel after reading your article. I feel very grateful that I read this. It is very helpful and very informative and I really learned a lot from it.Marbella

Anonymous said...


Hatur nhun ah anjeun tos ngijinan ka simkuring komentar di dieu

Obat Benjolan Di Payudara
Obat Nyeri Otot Paha Dan Betis
Obat Gagal Jantung
Obat Syaraf Kejepit
Obat Syaraf Kejepit
Cara Mengobati Nyeri Dada
Obat Sakit Pinggang
Obat Batuk Alergi

Gclub said...

Thanks for your sharing, it helps me a lot and I think I'll watch your post more.
………………………...

โกลเด้นสล็อต
ทางเข้า goldenslot

Gentin Club said...

Thanks for your sharing, it helps me a lot and I think I'll watch your post more.
…………………….
slotxo
สล็อตxo
ทางเข้า slotxo

sweta singh said...




With our Female Escorts in Chanakyapuriand escorts services, you may really improve stage of fun by its quality services different. Sure! This assists its people to victory over all the gloom and depressive disorders from your lifestyle and appeases your delicate wishes specifically.So, you may do a trip at web page and can get your wish suggested with an outstanding woman escort. Check our other services also...
Female Escorts in Chanakyapuri
Female Escorts in Chanakyapuri
Female Escorts in Chanakyapuri
Female Escorts in Connaught Place
Female Escorts in Connaught Place



Isha vermna said...

The time has come to explore the sexy services for the bold requirement and bold requirements can do with the right services. Mahipalpur Escorts are now going to show you the ultimate cool performance of sex and this performance may never forget by you when you choose the ultimate services of sex.

Mahipalpur Escorts
Mahipalpur Escorts

Ishika Sharma said...

Delhi Call Girls offer best sexual support you actually head. You can likewise have supper and sweet experience to know each other well before your implication. You can appreciate a sentimental candlelight supper with one another prior to beginning drawing near to one another as it would make a sentimental encounter and you may think of her as like your better half.

Sonam Sharma said...

Need the Best Call Girls? Call For Best Service in Udaipur


The finest features and qualities of Female Call Girls in Udaipur. Let us take a look at the options and the availability of the Udaipur Call Girls. Our Udaikkpur Call girls are supple and can stay with you the whole night. All our call girls are sexy, blonde, and well-informed and offer top Call Girls Service in Udaipur.

Udaipur call girls
Udaipur nude females
Udaipur escorts
Sexy Udaipur call girls


Sonam Sharma said...


South ex Call Girls Beauty with Killing Looks and Physique

Our call girls Escorts in the south ex area are modish and stunning babes to enlighten your privacy with our professional Escorts that understand to maintain confidentiality about your privacy.South ex call girls now bring you the most lucrative deal for companionship as well as intimacy at inexpensive prices.
South ex call girls
South ex escorts
Escorts in south ex
Sexy escort in south ex

Ishika Sharma said...

Along these lines, here we have all the lovely ladies for all your taste – the stunning, Brunette, Elite, Busty, Petite, and Fetish women. They'll certainly guarantee your 'definitive joy' for the spot With Kalkaji Escorts.

Babyescort said...

Hello Guys, Welcome to My Profile. I am Miss Delhi. I am an Independent Escort Girl in Delhi. I am just 21 years old. I am a Very Sexy Hot Girl. We offer the best High-Class Escort Girl in Delhi. Delhi escorts

Kavita Sharma said...


Nice Blog. Thanks for sharing this with us. Such amazing information.
Lucknow Escorts | Lucknow Call Girls | Call Girls in lucknow | Escorts in Lucknow | Read More

Lajpat Nagar Escorts said...

You are at the right place where your search for hot and luxurious escorts in Vasant Vihar escorts ends. Girls are highly trained to satisfy their customers upon entering this profession. Contact Now - 9311248576, https://www.callgirlsinmohali.in/vasant-vihar-escorts-service-delhi

Vasant Vihar escorts
Vasant Vihar escorts
Vasant Vihar escorts
Vasant Vihar escorts
Vasant Vihar escorts
Vasant Vihar escorts
Vasant Vihar escorts

Best sofa covers said...

Nice post! This is a very nice blog that I will definitely come back to more times this year!
Bestsofacovers.com provides a collection of the Best Sofa Products, Accessories, Reviews & Recommendations. Such as Sofa Covers, Pet Sofa Cover, Sofa Slipcover, Sofa Accessories & More. We have collected only the best sellers from amazon based on customer reviews and sales.
Best sofa Covers
Cheap sectional sofas under 500
Cheap sectional sofas under 300
Best couch for back support

Sonam Sharma said...

Good Looking and lovely VIP Call girls in Udaipur

Udaipur Call Girls offer the simplest top entertainment with sexy call girl Service. you've got an in depth choice between something more romantic up to some rough sodomy . These are just a few of the samples of the items that are possible whenever you desire to feel the proper way and fully satisfied with the highest class call girls.

Udaipur call girls
Udaipur escorts
Udaipur call girl

Escorts in udaipur

Sonam Sharma said...

Enjoy Munirka Call girl Services in the city
Our munirka call girls are always willing to offer some attractive naughty offers. it'll get the simplest rates longer with ladies like escorts or others with some pleasure.You can have munirka call girls for your night fun. Also the middle City ladies as perfect Old so far companions.


Munirka Call girl
Munirka Call girls
Escorts in Munirka 
Munirka escorts

Sonam Sharma said...

Spend sensual bold day with Janakpuri call girls

Janakpuri call girls never let their charm and horniness fritter away because they know once it goes away then it will be hard to get it back.All Janakpuri call girl are highly qualified and dress to kill to kill people You can appoint model call girl directly from the website or call us for further inquiry.

Call girl in janakpuri
janakpuri escorts

Lajpat Nagar Escorts said...

On the other hand, Young College Girls Escorts in Paharganj is also good for the pleasure of the customers and that’s why they can grab the best pleasure moments with these call girls. There is no need to worry about the bad things because Young College Escorts Call Girls are always ready to make sure your sexual satisfaction in the right way

Paharganj escorts
Paharganj escorts
Paharganj escorts
Paharganj escorts
Paharganj escorts
Paharganj escorts

Sonam Sharma said...

Good Looking and lovely VIP Call girls in Udaipur


Udaipur Call Girls offer the simplest top entertainment with sexy call girl Service. you've got an in depth choice between something more romantic up to some rough sodomy . These are just a few of the samples of the items that are possible whenever you desire to feel the proper way and fully satisfied with the highest class call girls.

Udaipur call girls

Megha Malik said...

Delhi High Class Escorts
Delhi Fantasy Escorts
Delhi High Class Escorts
Delhi High Class Escorts
Delhi High Class Escorts
Delhi High Class Escorts
high class Mumbai escorts

Diyanka Call Girls said...

Are you getting bored with your ordinary life? then you must hire our naughty call girl for your fun. Our girls will give you their best services along with stunning erotic massage
Dwarka call girls
Call Girls in Vaishali
Hauz Khas Escorts Service
East of Kailash Escorts
Escorts in Connaught Place

chennaidesire said...

Call girls are available at very cheap rates at our escorts agency.
call girls in punjabi bagh
dwarka Call Girls
east of kailash Escorts
Escorts in connaught place
munirka Escorts Service

Beautiful Lady Love said...

manali escorts##
call girls service in manali##

poojakherindependent said...

Indian Escorts

cheap Escorts Delhi

Cheap Escorts Delhi

Independent Escorts Delhi

connaught place escorts

Busty Escorts in Mumbai

Unknown said...

What Is The Price Of Bitcoin In The USA?

It is the most repeated question that is asked by most investors. The Price Of Bitcoin varies according to demand and need. Now you can follow the steps to open your bitcoin account.

Logan Amber said...

Bitcoin ATM Service Phone Number Even those who made small investments in bitcoin can now make large sums of money.

This ATM offers greater privacy, which is a major reason why it should be used. Bitcoin buying. The Support phone number for Bitcoin ATM It is the best option for all your buying needs. It is a low-tech option for people who are less tech-savvy and have lower bank accounts. Bitcoin ATM support phone number

Lucas Mason said...

Bitcoin ATM support phone number

It is a low-tech, low-banked option that can help people with fewer techs alert. Bitcoin ATM support phone number This ATM offers greater privacy, which is a major reason why it should be used. Bitcoin buying. The Support phone number for Bitcoin ATM It is the best option for all your buying needs.

Lucas Mason said...

BTC Customer Service Contact & Live Chat

If You Searching BTC Customer Service Content do visit our website.BTC Customer Service Contact