Saturday, October 8, 2011

A Baby Cadborosaur No More. Part 8b: The Bay Pipefish

Poachers, despite a startling similarity to Hagelund's illustrated specimen, are problematic candidates as they are apparently incapable of undulatory locomotion and at-surface behavior is unlikely. Pipefishes don't look as similar but are capable of undulating at the surface and can be unambiguously described as "eel-like" or "sea snake-like"... unlike Hagelund's own drawing.

Syngnathus leptorhynchus from Flickr user jmandecki.
Syngnathus leptorhynchus from Flickr user jmandecki.

Hagelund's drawing portrays the upper bounds of the estimated depth (1-1.5 inches), so the difference from the above pictures of Bay Pipefish (Syngnathus leptorhynchus) may not be as great as shown. Bay Pipefish have been recorded up to 38.5 cm in total length (Bayer 1980) - comfortably similar to 40 cm, I'd say - and it seems likely that allometry could make them more similar to the Hagelund specimen. The equation Bayer (1980) used to estimate pipefish weight from length indicated that the fish were proportionally more massive at larger sizes (the rate was somewhat higher than cubed) and the largest specimens tended to be underestimated in weight; this suggests that Bay Pipefish are proportionally thicker-bodied at large sizes. Another potential explanation is that Hagelund captured a pregnant male; males are somewhat smaller than females with a maximum size of 32.5 cm TL (Bayer 1980), although this is within a plausible margin of error, considering the Hagelund specimen was estimated rather than measured. It seems that there is some variation in Bay Pipefish head length (see below) which may be related to size as well.

† log W = -3.70 + 3.12 log TL(cm)

A rather thick Bay Pipefish from Wikipedia Commons.

Bay Pipefish match the described behavior and shape of the Hagelund specimen as well as the coloration, long snout, slender head, lips, and large dark eyes; the pelvic fins are absent and the dorsal and anal fins are small and transparent enough to be easily overlooked. The snout of the Hagelund specimen has a similar profile to that of a Bay Pipefish (with a bulbous protrusion at the end) which Hagelund mysteriously labels as a "hooked upper jaw". The Bay Pipefish lacks hair-like structures, although the mesh-like coloration on the ventrum (somewhat visible above) could potentially explain this trait; there is such a thing as a Hairy Pipefish, but they are found nowhere near the northeast Pacific. The biggest issues with the Bay Pipefish are the lack of teeth and whisker-like structures. Hagelund's illustration is very unclear as to where the whiskers are located (the original illustration is full of mysteriously interpretive lines), but since they protruded from the head, they can't be due to coloration and it would be implausible for Hagelund to mistake the pectoral fins for separate structures. All pipefish lack teeth, however some have inconspicuous tooth-like odontoid processes (Dawson and Fritzsche 1975)... which have not been described from S. leptorhynchus.


Bay Pipefish are not a perfect fit for the Hagelund specimen, but then, nothing is. Since the pipefish is more similar than any other northeast Pacific fish, the most reasonable conclusion is that the differences are due to the account being misremembered after nearly two decades. Perfect recollection after such a time period (or any time period, really) is probably impossible. Even if it turns out that poachers can fit the described behavior or there's some better fitting fish out there, the point will stand: LeBlond and Bousfield's identification of this creature as a cryptid is one of the least likely solutions available. Besides, if the account were to be taken literally, it would be some sort of weird, tiny, armored pinniped.

But wait, there's more! I'll quickly review the other weird candidates we dredged up and then it's time for an executive summary.


References:

Bayer, R. D. (1980). Size, Seasonality, and Sex Ratios of the Bay Pipefish (Syngnathus leptorhynchus) in Oregon. Northwest Science 54 (3), 161-167. Available.

Dawson, C. E. and Fritzsche, R. A. (1975). Odontoid processes in pipefish jaws. Nature 257, 390. doi:10.1038/257390a0

Hagelund, W. A. (1987). Whalers No More. Vancouver: Harbour Publishing.

LeBlond, P. H. & Bousfield, E. L. (1995). Cadborosaurus, Survivor from the Deep. Victoria, British Columbia: Horsdal & Schubart.

Woodley, M. A., Naish, D. & McCormick, C. A. (2011). A Baby Sea-Serpent No More: Reinterpreting Hagelund's Juvenile "Cadborosaur" Report. Journal of Scientific Exploration 25(3), 495-512.


Previous entries:
A Baby Cadborosaur No More. Part 4: What is 'Cadborosaurus'?
A Baby Cadborosaur No More. Part 5: Hagelund's Specimen And The Cadborosaurus
A Baby Cadborosaur No More. Part 6a: Cold Water on the 'Reptilian Hypothesis'
A Baby Cadborosaur No More. Part 6b: Reptilian Reproduction
A Baby Cadborosaur No More. Part 7: Poachers
A Baby Cadborosaur No More. Part 8a: Pipefish in a Bucket

Tet Zoo Coverage: 
A baby sea-serpent no more: reinterpreting Hagelund’s juvenile Cadborosaurus

12 comments:

Robert Jennifer said...

The poem means what it says. To paraphrase it is to kill it. Read it very carefully and bring to it your own associations with the words used. You and the poet should meet about half way.επιπλα

sydneyswimmers.com.au/ said...

sydneyswimmers.com.au/ are the providing the best coaches in Sydney and if you are looking for free classes then call us now at 0431 571 161

Anonymous said...

thanks for your info .. sepintasas mengenai Asam Urat. Apa itu Asam urat? Asam urat adalah zat sisa hasil dari metabolisme purin dari sisa makanan yang telah kita konsumsi. Asam urat tersebut akan dikeluarkan melalui kotoran atau urine. Tetapi, jika asam masuk secara berlebihan maka ginjal tidak bisa mengeluarkan asam urat tersebut dan akan menumpuk di dalam persendian, biasanya penyebab asam urat menumpuk karena buang air yang tidak lancar. Akibatnya persendian menjadi bengkak dan menyebabkan sulit untuk berjalan. Makan yang Dianjurkan bagi penderita Penyakit Asam Urat

Sayuran segar seperti salada, jagung, tomat, kentang
Buah-buahan yang dianjurkan seperti, pisang jeruk, stroberie, chery, jeruk nipis
Perbanyak juga meminum Air mineral
Konsumsi jus Lemon

Obat aman untuk ibu hamil berkhasiat said...

Obat gatal di selangkangan
Obat maag untuk ibu hamil
Obat Paru Paru Basah
Obat penurun darah tinggi

Unknown said...

OBAT BATUK
OBAT ASMA
OBAT ASMA
OBAT ASMA
OBAT BATUK

Kez0223 said...

It is interesting to read, I hope the future is much better

Gejala Hernia Dan Cara Untuk Mengatasinya Secara Tradisional
Gejala Hernia Yang Perlu Diwaspadai Baik Pria Maupun Wanita
Gejala Hernia Paling Mujarab Tanpa OPerasi
Gejala Hernia Pada Wanita Yang Biasa Muncul

Kez0223 said...

Nice to be visiting your blog again, i was just browsing along and came upon your blog. just wanted to say good blog and this article really helped me.

Gejala Asam Urat Dini Dan Cara Pencegahannya Yang Baik
Gejala Asam Urat Dan Kolesterol Tinggi Patut Diwaspadai
Gejala Asam Urat Dan Solusinya
Gejala Asam Urat Pada Wanita Yang Harus Diwaspadai

Gejala Asam Urat Yang Sering Muncul Pada Umumnya
Gejala Asam Urat Reumatik Akut
Gejala Asam Urat Tinggi Dan Cara Untuk Mengatasinya

Unknown said...

Cara Mengobati Varikokel Tanpa Operasi
hai gan / sist ya sorry I visit your article, because I am really interested sihh, it lohh article. oh he me it was fine the passengers, passengers kept a link wrote not nyepam kok.he Thank you :)

Harga Jelly Gamat

Anonymous said...

pengalaman pertama kali menderita wasir
pentingnya kesadaran mengenai penyakit wasir
penyakit wasir ambeien dan obatnya
harus kemanakah untuk konsultasi kencing nanah
manfaat susu kedelai

De Nature Indonesia said...

Obat Kutil Kelamin Aman
Gejala Kutil kelamin
Ciri-ciri Kutil Kelamin
Obat Kutil Kelamin Herbal
Ubat Ketuat Kemaluan Denature

Anonymous said...

Harga Jual Obat Kutil Kelamin Dan Sipilis Denature
Gejala Dan Obat Kutil Kelamin Pria Dan Wanita
Kutil Kelamin Pada Ibu Hamil DiBantul
Cara Menghilangkan Ketuat Kelamin DiBanyuasin
Kutil Kelamin Saat Hamil DiBanyumas

Unknown said...

Nice work with good ideas and concepts, lots of great information which we all need, helpful information. I would like to thank you for the efforts you shown remarkable writing skill in this article
Obat Wasir atau Ambeien Dari Bahan Herbal 
OBAT AMBEIEN TANPA OPERASI? AMBEJOSS DAN SALWA JAWABANNYA!
Obat Ambeien Ampuh
Cara mengobati ambeien tradisional
Obat Ambeien atau wasir untuk ibu hamil